| Screaming Shy Guys | |
|---|---|
 Y05H1M4N's Screaming Shy Guys Logo | |
|
Number of Members |
13 |
|
Highest Ranking |
TBA |
|
Lowest Ranking |
Birdo, 25th Place |
|
Team selected by |
Toad |
The Screaming Shy Guys are one of the two teams on Toadal Drama Island. The other is the Killer Koopas.
Challenges
Cliff Jump: Won Challenge
Sleep-o-thon: Lost Challenge, Birdo was Eliminated
Dodgeball: Lost Challenge, Toadsworth was Eliminated
Talent Show: Lost Challenge, E. Gadd was Eliminated
Camp out: Lost Challenge, Morton was Eliminated
Phobia Factor: Lost Challenge, Waluigi was Eliminated
Bony Island: Lost Challenge, Wario Quit
Paintball Deerhunt: Won Challenge
Cook-off: Won Challenge
Members
Original Members
- Birdo
- Boo
- Bowser
- Dry Bones
- E. Gadd
- Larry Koopa
- Mario
- Morton Koopa Jr.
- Toadsworth
- Trooper
- Waluigi
- Wario
- Wendy O. Koopa
Team Elimination Order
| Name | Team Ranking | Overall Ranking | Reason | Episode Eliminated |
| Birdo | 13th | 25th | Put himself to sleep because Yoshi told him to, failing the challenge for his team. | The Big Sleep |
| Toadsworth | 12th | 24th | Failed alot in the dodgeball challenge. | Dodgebrawl |
| E. Gadd | 11th | 23rd | Talent was sabatoged by Ludwig which caused it to try to attack Toad. | Not Quite Famous |
| Morton | 10th | 22nd | Annoyied everyone on his team and attracted a bear to their camp. | The Sucky Outdoors |
| Waluigi | 9th | 21st | Failed the final phobia challenge and called Wario fat. | Phobia Factor |
| Wario | 8th | 20th | Quit because he felt guilty for voting out Waluigi. | Up the Creek |
Trivia
- The Screaming Shy Guys are the Toadal Drama Island equivilent of The Screaming Staff Members.
- Mario has caused every elimination on his team except for Morton's.