ILVG Wiki
Advertisement

Has this ever happened to you?

"Man, Carl and Luigi's eliminations were so unfair! I freaking hate Petey and Daisy!"

Well than look no further than this what if!

What if Petey never voted off Carl?

Now you might be thinking, "Wait, how is saving Carl gonna save Luigi?" Well Daisy eliminated Luigi because he eliminated Carl accidentally. So, if Carl is saved then Luigi is saved.

Island Anonymous

ISLAND ANONYMOUS.jpg

So Petey has 3 options, either eliminate Peach, Kamek, or Daisy. I will go through all of them. How you may ask. Well, we shall do separate timelines. The first, or Timeline #2(since timeline #1 is the original) which is the most likely, is Peach being eliminated thanks to Mimi, Timeline #3 is Kamek being eliminated thanks to Daisy, and Timeline #4 is Daisy being eliminated thanks to Kamek, which is the least likely to happen. You might be thinking, "Wait, couldn't Luigi vote off Mimi?" Well, he could, but the show wouldn't be interesting without an antagonist won't it?

Finders Keepers

FINDERS KEEPERS.jpg

Timeline #2

Without Peach Bowser would still vote Daisy since he sort of trust Mimi. Carl and Daisy would vote with each other. Also, Carl would tell Daisy about how Mimi broke up Peach and Bowser so now they don't trust Mimi. Daisy would still vote Yoshi since he and Mimi are allies.

  • Null Boo- Voted for Yoshi maybe since Yoshi must have had votes against him. Doesn't make sense, but it's all I got.
  • Bowser- Voted for Daisy since Mimi posed as Peach to get Bowser's vote.
  • Carl- Voted for Yoshi He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally.
  • Daisy- Voted for Yoshi per Carl's reason.
  • Kamek- Voted for Daisy since he thinks she's annoying.
  • Luigi- Voted for Yoshi Why would he vote for his girlfriend?
  • Mimi- Voted for Daisy since she was drowned in lava because of her. Plus, she confermed it in the next episode.
  • Petey- Voted for Daisy since "The Marshmallow Man" told him to vote for a female.
  • Yoshi- Voted for Daisy Per Mimi's reason.

I tried to see if I could vote off Yoshi, but It's the same outcome, but with Luigi and Carl and without Peach. Anyway, 5 votes for Daisy and 4 votes for Yoshi. Just to add drama let's say that Daisy tries to take Luigi because he doesn't deserve to win, but at the last second, Luigi was seen by Toad and was almost eliminated. Luigi then decides to step out of the shadows again since he doesn't want that to happen again.

Peach, Daisy,

Timeline #3

This episode doesn't really change, but now Daisy and Petey are officially friends since he got Kamek out.

  • Null Boo- Voted for Yoshi maybe since Yoshi must have had votes against him. Doesn't make sense, but it's all I got.
  • Bowser- Voted for Daisy since Mimi posed as Peach to get Bowser's vote.
  • Carl- Voted for Yoshi He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally.
  • Daisy- Voted for Yoshi per Carl's reason.
  • Luigi- Voted for Yoshi Why would he vote for his girlfriend?
  • Mimi- Voted for Daisy since she was drowned in lava because of her. Plus she confirmed it in the next episode.
  • Peach- Voted for Yoshi maybe per Boo's reason.
  • Petey- Voted for Daisy reluctantly since "The Marshmallow Man" told him to vote for a female.
  • Yoshi- Voted for Daisy Per Mimi's reason.

Well Mimi's plan didn't work out. Should've gotten Peach's vote. 5 votes for Yoshi and 4 votes for Daisy.

Kamek, Yoshi,

Timeline #4

Since Daisy's gone, no one can understand Carl. He decides to ally with Luigi with their mutual distrust of Mimi. How you may ask? Well Carl can just draw it out. He's surprisingly a good artist. (Don't know if that's true. Only did this so that he could be saved.) Also, I'm just assuming that Carl could see Luigi the whole time. There's only one person that Mimi can eliminate now...(assuming that she doesn't eliminate Carl)

  • Null Boo- Voted for Yoshi maybe since Yoshi must of had votes against him. Doesn't make sense, but it's all I got.
  • Bowser- Voted for Yoshi since Mimi posed as Peach to get Bowser's vote.
  • Carl- Voted for Yoshi He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally
  • Kamek- Voted for Petey since he thinks he's annoying.
  • Luigi- Voted for Yoshi Why would he vote for his girlfriend?
  • Mimi- Voted for Yoshi She confirmed it in the next episode.
  • Peach- Voted for Yoshi maybe per Boo's reason.
  • Petey- Voted for Yoshi "The Marshmallow Man" told him to vote for a male.
  • Yoshi- Voted for Petey Per Kamek's reason.

Yeah ... Petey was the reason that Yoshi's gone in this episode. 7 votes for Yoshi and 2 votes for Petey.

Daisy, Yoshi,

SUPER BOWSER 64

SUPER BOWSER 64.jpg

Timeline #2

Without Peach Bowser would still be in the game and with Luigi still here, the votes will be very different. Also, Carl is allied with Luigi like in Timeline #4.

  • Null Boo- Voted for Mimi Do I even need to explain?
  • Bowser- Voted for Petey He trusts Mimi for some reason.
  • Carl- Voted for Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Kamek- Voted for Petey because he's annoying and he also shrunken him plus he'll never vote for "King Bowser."
  • Luigi- Voted for Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Mimi- Voted for Bowser All according to her plan.
  • Petey- Voted for Bowser Since he's being trick by Mimi.
  • Yoshi- Voted for Bowser Per Petey's reason.

So, we have our first tie! I was thinking to do a double elimination, but I can't get rid of the antagonist, (yet) so Bowser loses the tiebreaker.

Peach, Daisy, Bowser,

Timeline #3

Other than Luigi, Daisy, and Carl being here and Yoshi not being here, is there any changes?

  • Null Boo- Voted for Bowser because Peach told her to.
  • Bowser- Voted for Mimi because she tried to ruin his and Peach's relationship.
  • Carl- Voted for Mimi He considered voting Bowser, but Mimi being in a cannon is better than Bowser.
  • Daisy- Voted for Mimi since her and Carl are BFFs.
  • Luigi- Voted for Bowser Maybe since he's still invisible. Maybe he overheard Peach.
  • Mimi- Hard to say who she voted for but maybe Bowser since she had a plan to vote him off, which didn't work as intended.
  • Peach- Voted for Bowser since she likes him too much and thought either her or Bowser was on the chopping block if she voted off Mimi.
  • Petey- Voted for Bowser Per Boo's reason.

So, 5 votes for Bowser, 3 votes for Mimi, and 1 vote for Petey. Nothing changes from Timeline #1.

Kamek, Yoshi, Bowser,

Timeline #4

Like Starlow did for Toadette, Carl wants a, "I hate Mimi" or "I want Mimi gone!" club, but Luigi isn't sure if everyone hates Mimi, but he tries anyway

  • Null Boo- Voted for Bowser maybe since Yoshi must have had votes against him. Doesn't make sense, but it's all I got.
  • Bowser- Voted for Mimi since he doesn't trust her.
  • Carl- Voted for Mimi He can finally get rid of her.
  • Kamek- Voted for Petey since he thinks he's annoying.
  • Luigi- Voted for Mimi Per Carl's reason.
  • Mimi- Hard to say who she voted for but maybe Bowser since she had a plan to vote him off, which didn't work as intended.
  • Peach- Voted for Bowser since she likes him too much and thought either her or Bowser was on the chopping block if she voted off Mimi.
  • Petey- Voted for Bowser per Boo's reason.

So, 4 votes for Bowser, 3 votes for Mimi, and 1 vote for Petey. Bowser just can't catch a break.

Daisy, Yoshi, Bowser,

JUST COLD KARTED

JUST COLD KARTED.jpg

Timeline #2

I'm pretty sure that this is the same, but with Carl and Luigi replacing Peach.

  • Boo- Voted for Kamek Mimi is immune so this is the next best thing.
  • Carl- Voted for Petey Per Boo's reason.
  • Kamek- Voted for Yoshi Since he trust Mimi.
  • Luigi- Voted for Kamek Per Boo's reason.
  • Null Mimi- Voted for Yoshi she want's Peach to be alone.
  • Petey- Voted for Yoshi Per Kamek's reason.
  • Yoshi- Voted for Boo To get on Mimi's good side.

So, 3 votes for Yoshi, 2 votes for Kamek, and 1 vote for Boo and Petey. Same thing happens again, but Boo replaces Peach.

Peach, Daisy, Bowser, Yoshi,

Timeline #3

Since Mimi has invincibility and Yoshi's gone, she has a new target.

  • Boo- Voted for Daisy Mimi is immune so this is the next best thing.
  • Carl- Voted for Petey He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally.
  • Daisy- Voted for Boo since she doesn't want to vote for Petey, and Mimi posed as Luigi to get her vote.
  • Luigi- Voted for Petey Why would he vote off his girlfriend?
  • Null Mimi- Voted for Boo she want's Peach to be alone.
  • Peach- Voted for Daisy Per Boo's reason.
  • Petey- Voted for Boo Per Boo's reason.

So, 3 votes for Boo and 2 votes for Petey and Daisy. Sorry Boo fans. Am I gonna get Boo's? I'm sorry, I'll admit that was bad.

Kamek, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo,

Timeline #4

Since no Daisy, how will this play out?

  • Boo- Voted for Kamek since Mimi was immune and he was a threat.
  • Carl- Voted for Petey He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally
  • Kamek- Voted for Boo since he trusts Mimi for some reason.
  • Luigi- Voted for Kamek Per Boo's reason.
  • Null Mimi- Voted for Boo She confirmed it in the next episode.
  • Peach- Voted for Kamek per Boo's reason.
  • Petey- Voted for Boo since he trust Mimi.

So, another tie happens. Double Elimination Time! Had to be one somewhere. Sorry Kamek and Boo fans. Also, Boo can't use the cannon, so she just flies away.

Daisy, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo and Kamek,

TRAGIC MAGIC

TRAGIC MAGIC.jpg

Timeline #2

Since Peach isn't here Mimi has a new mission: eliminate Peach's friends so that they don't share the money.

  • Boo- Voted for Mimi Do I need to explain?
  • Carl- Voted for Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Kamek- Voted for Mimi per Boo's reason.
  • Luigi- Voted for Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Mimi- Voted for Boo Her new mission.
  • Null Petey- Voted for Himself he thought he was signing up for free candy.
Toad: One vote for Mimi.
Mimi growls
Toad: One vote for Boo.
Boo: Predictable much?
Toad: One vote for ... Petey you can't vote yourself off, you have invincibility.
Petey: I thought we were signing up for free candy.
Toad: sigh The final 2 votes go to... Huge dramatic pause Mimi. Sorry, but you're out of here!

Peach, Daisy, Bowser, Yoshi, Mimi,

Timeline #3

Since no Kamek Mimi sadly wins invincibility.

  • Carl- Voted for Petey He's knocking Mimi down a peg by voting off her ally.
  • Daisy- Voted for Mimi Didn't want to vote off Petey.
  • Luigi- Voted for Petey Per Carl's reason.
  • Null Mimi- Voted for Peach Do I even need to explain.
  • Peach- Voted for Petey Per Carl's reason.
  • Petey- Voted for Himself he thought he was signing up for free candy.
Toad: One vote for Petey. One vote for Peach.
Peach: Predictable much?
Toad: One vote for … Daisy why did you vote for Mimi?
Daisy: I couldn’t vote off my buddy!
Toad: One vote for Petey. Why is there a self-vote?
Petey: I thought we were signing up for free candy.
Toad: sigh The final vote goes to... Huge dramatic pause Petey. Sorry, but you're out of here!
Petey: Wait, what's going on?
Toad: You are no longer competing. Go to the cannon of shame.
Petey: What?! Why did you guys vote me off!?
Peach, Luigi, and Daisy: Because Mimi had immunity.
Petey: Aww... Well good luck you guys!

Kamek, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, Petey,

Timeline #4

Let's see what happens if Mimi never ate Kamek's wand.

  • Carl- Voted for Mimi Do I even need to explain?
  • Luigi- Voted for Mimi Per Carl's reason.
  • Mimi- Voted for Peach Per Carl's reason.
  • Peach- Voted for Mimi per Carl's reason.
  • Null Petey- Voted for Himself he thought he was signing up for free candy.
Toad: One vote for Mimi.
Mimi growls
Toad: One vote for Peach.
Peach: Predictable much?
Toad: One vote for ... Petey you can't vote yourself off, you have invincibility.
Petey: I thought we were signing up for free candy.
Toad: sigh The final vote go to... Huge dramatic pause Mimi. Sorry, but you're out of here!
Mimi: What?! I'll crush you! I'll kill you all! [turns into the spider Mimi] Mimimimimimimimi!
Kamek: I got this! [turns Mimi small] Please put her into the cannon before it wears off.
Toad: Any finals words Mimi?
Mimi: [high pitched since she's small] I [CENCERED] HATE ALL OF YOU! ALL OF YOU, G-
Toad: I'm doing the same thing I did to Toadette. [the cannon then fires]
Mimi: I WILL HAVE My revenge!
Peach: Finally.

Daisy, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo and Kamek, Mimi,

REVENGE OF THE CAMEOS

REVENGE OF THE CAMEOS.jpg

Timeline #2

Down to the final five! The final five still do the challenge, but the person who completes the challenge wins invincibility for the final time which means the final challenge shall belong to the final 3!

  • Boo- Couldn't "vote" since this challenge is rigged against her but would've voted for Petey possibly since she's friends with Kamek and on good terms with Carl.
  • Carl- "Voted for" Kamek since at this point, he's a threat and wizard.
  • Kamek- "Voted for" Carl He thinks that Petey and Boo are too easy to defeat.
  • Luigi- "Voted for" Kamek since he's a threat.
  • Petey- "Voted for" Kamek since he's a Meany and a butt face for insulting Petey.

The same thing with Petey winning (with the help of Carl) and quitting living the final 3 as Boo, Carl, and Luigi. The Intangible Duo vs Carl. I'm going to say that Carl comes in 3rd and Luigi comes in 1st! (doing this for the Luigi fans) Sorry Carl, better luck next season!

Peach, Daisy, Bowser, Yoshi, Mimi, Kamek and Petey, Carl, Boo, and Luigi.

Timeline #3

Poor Boo with her ghost-ly ness

  • Boo- Couldn't "vote" since this challenge is rigged against her, but would've voted for Mimi Do I even need to explain?
  • Carl- "Voted for" Mimi Per Boo's reason
  • Daisy- "Voted for" Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Luigi- "Voted for" Mimi Per Boo's reason.
  • Mimi- Voted for Peach Per Boo's reason.
  • Peach- Voted for Mimi Per Boo's reason.

I'm gonna say that Peach wins so it's time for vote #2!

  • Carl- Voted for ____ They are a threat because of their ____________.
  • Daisy- Voted for ____ Can't vote off ____.
  • Luigi- Voted for ____ They're pretty smart.
  • Null Peach- Voted for ____ They're a threat.

Keeping the votes hidden for now.

Toad: Seams Everyone's got a vote against them. Everyone except Peach. She gets the first and her last mushroom.
Peach: Finale here I come!
Toad: Luigi is also safe. Why do you keep disappearing?!
Luigi: [Makes himself known] I'm right here. Sorry!
Toad: Here's your mushroom and your ticket in the finale. Daisy and Carl, one off you will be in the finale and the other won't. The final mushroom and another shot at the one million coins goes to
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Peach: Can you get on with it?!
Toad: The audience likes the tension so don't rush me!
Peach sighs
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Carl starts to babble
Daisy: Carl says to hurry up.
Toad: What did I just say?!
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Toad: Daisy.
Carl babbles again
Daisy: WHAT?! growls You will pay for voting off Carl!

I'm going to reveal the votes and the reasons later. Now Daisy tries to make sure that Luigi and Peach loses, but Luigi is mostly invisible (to Daisy) so Peach almost wins, but Daisy jumps in front of her at the last second. Little did they know Luigi was already done.

Kamek, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, Petey, Mimi and Carl, Peach, Daisy, and Luigi.

Timeline #4

Pretty similar to #2.

  • Carl- Voted for Peach She's a threat.
  • Luigi- Voted for Petey Per Carl's reason.
  • Peach- "Voted for" Petey since at this point, he's a threat and wizard.
  • Petey- "Voted for" Unknown He doesn't have anyone to vote for.

Daisy, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo and Kamek, Mimi, Petey, Peach, Luigi, and Carl.

See you when I make another Blog! Bye! 👋

Advertisement